A malignant pleural effusion in a patient with localized lung cancer is a poor prognostic finding and usually excludes the patient from a definitive surgical resection. On the other hand a patient with non-malignant pleural fluid may make a good surgical candidate.
Goal: To determine if a patient with a localized lung cancer and pleural fluid accumulation is a candidate for surgical resection of the lung cancer.
Parameters:
(1) type of fluid (transudate, non-bloody exudates, bloody exudates)
(2) probable cause (metastatic cancer, heart failure, other)
(3) results of pleural cytology (based on at least 2 examinations if the first is negative)
The presence of a bloody exudates is usually indicative of a malignant pleural effusion although there may be other explanations.
Type of Fluid |
Probable Cause |
Cytology |
Surgical Candidate |
transudate |
other than cancer |
negative |
good |
bloody exudates |
lung cancer |
positive |
very poor |
exudate |
other than cancer |
negative |
fair |
transudate |
lung cancer |
negative |
fair |
NA |
NA |
positive |
poor |
other |
other |
other |
guarded |
It is important not to deny surgery to a patient with lung cancer who may benefit from it. On the other hand one should not put a patient through the trauma of surgery if there will be no benefit.
Specialty: Hematology Oncology, Surgery, general, Pulmonology