Description

Malignant tumors have rarely occurred at sites of previous trauma. Stoll and Crissey listed criteria for establishing a causative association between a traumatic event and a subsequent malignant tumor. These were based on the criteria listed by Ewing in 1926.


 

Criteria:

(1) The skin must previously have been normal.

(2) Adequate and authenticated trauma must have occurred.

(3) The tumor should be a primary neoplasm consistent with tissues at the site. The possibility of a metastasis to the site must be excluded.

(4) The carcinoma must originate from the exact point of injury.

(5) A reasonable time interval between the trauma and the first appearance of the carcinoma must be present.

(6) There must be a continuity of physical signs from the traumatic event to the appearance of the carcinoma.

 

Issues:

(1) A single episode of trauma may be sufficient.

(2) Tumors may metastasize to sites of increased vascularity like sites of trauma or fracture. I have seen lung cancer present as a metastasis to a fractured thumb.

(3) The latency period may range from a few months to 35 years or more. Thiem proposed a minimum period of 3 weeks in 1909, but that seems too short a period to me.

(4) It would be essential to exclude chemical toxic injury to the site and radiation injury.

(5) Authentication of the original trauma is best done by a physician after a complete examination.

 


To read more or access our algorithms and calculators, please log in or register.