Keratoconjunctivitis sicca (KCS) may occur in patients with Sjogren's syndrome, or it may occur in patients with age-related decrease in tear gland function. Tests of tear function may be abnormal in these 2 groups of patients. While no one test can distinguish between the two groups of patients, combinations of tests sometimes can.
Tests of tear function:
(1) lactoferrin concentration, as determined by immunoprecipitation: Lactoferrin is secreted in the tear gland acini but not in the tubular portions of the gland.
(2) wetting of a filter paper strip for 5 minutes (Schirmer test): measures tear fluid production
(3) tear film breakup time: measures tear film instability and is related to the protein concentration in the tear fluid
(4) Rose bengal score: reflects secondary damage to the superficial epithelium of the cornea and conjunctiva
(5) lysozyme: Lysozyme is secreted by both the acini and the tubular structures of the tear gland.
The first 3 were selected for developing a discriminant score.
Test Results |
Sjogren's KCS |
non-Sjogren's age-related KCS |
---|---|---|
lactoferrin concentration (mean) |
478 |
799 |
Schirmer test in mm (median) |
4 |
7 |
tear film breakup time in seconds (mean) |
3 |
5 |
(Table 1, page 115)
discriminant function =
= (-0.083 * (diameter of lactoferrin precipitation in mm)) - (0.0219 * (wetting of filter paper strip at 5 minutes in mm)) - (0.1414 * (tear break-up in seconds))
Interpretation:
• Only patients who clinically have keratoconjunctivitis sicca should be evaluated.
• If the discriminant function is greater than or equal to the breakpoint selected, then the patient is said to have Sjogren's keratoconjunctivitis.
• If the discriminant function is less than the breakpoint, then the patient is said to have age-related, non-Sjogren's keratoconjunctivitis.
|
Probability of Misclassifying |
|
---|---|---|
Breakpoint |
if say non-Sjogren's and patient has Sjogren's KCS |
if say Sjogren's and the patient has non-Sjogren's age-related KCS |
-0.40 |
0% |
100% |
-0.79 |
20% |
73% |
-1.19 |
37% |
33% |
-1.59 |
53% |
20% |
-1.99 |
67% |
3% |
-2.39 |
73% |
3% |
-2.79 |
90% |
0% |
-3.19 |
100% |
0% |
(Table 2, page 115)
Equations from JMP to describe the plot of breakpoint versus probability of misclassifying a patient:
percent misclassification of a patient with Sjogren's KCS at a given breakpoint (from 0 to 100) =
= (-4.58 * ((discriminant function)^2)) - (51.375 * (discriminant function)) - 18.499
for breakpoints >= -1.99, the percent misclassification of a patient with non-Sjogren's KCS at a given breakpoint (from 0 to 100) =
= (21.93 * ((discriminant function)^2)) + (114.44 * (discriminant function)) + 144.11
Purpose: To distinguish between keratoconjunctivitis (KCS) due to Sjogren's disease and age-related KCS using tear function tests.
Specialty: Ophthalmology, Immunology/Rheumatology
Objective: differential diagnosis and mimics, red flags
ICD-10: H19.3,